Advertisement

Executive Adviser

Innovation

Shape of Things To Come

By David Orozco and James Conley

May 12, 2008

How Apple's trademark for its iPod protects its brand—and offers lessons for other companies on how to leverage their intellectual property

This article is free to subscribers. Subscribe today.

On Jan. 8, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office granted Apple Inc. a trademark for the three-dimensional shape of its iPod media player.

This was more than a recognition of an innovative product design. It also was Apple’s capping piece in a multiyear marketing and legal campaign that pushed intellectual-property rights to new competitive advantage for the company.

In many ways, Apple is benefiting from an expansion of U.S. trademark rights, beyond the traditional names, images, logos and two-dimensional symbols trademarks usually secure. In recent years, trademarks have been granted for such things as product shapes, colors and scents that companies can claim are linked exclusively to the source company in consumers’ minds.

Shaping Up
  • What’s Happening: Companies are obtaining new kinds of trademarks, securing exclusive rights to product features such as shape, scent and color. A vivid example came earlier this year, when Apple registered the three-dimensional shape of iPods as a trademark.
  • Why It’s Important: Trademarks, unlike patents, can last forever, and so provide a potent new marketing weapon against rival products. Apple now has an open-ended ability to sue media-player makers and distributors when their products resemble too closely the shape of an iPod.
  • How It’s Done: The Patent Office doesn’t make it easy to register a nontraditional trademark. But other companies can learn from Apple’s campaign, which involved multiple patents, trademarks and advertising.

These nontraditional marks are difficult to obtain. But unlike more commonly used utility and design patents, which exist to cover functions and the ornamental look and feel of products and expire after a set number of years, trademarks can remain in force potentially forever.

The iPod shape trademark gives Apple a new weapon in the fiercely competitive market for media players. While competitors may eventually appropriate the iPod’s inner workings, as utility patents expire, they will risk litigation if their products come too close to the trademarked shape of the iPod, including its popular circular-touchpad interface. Moreover, trademark law allows the holder to sue not only manufacturers but also distributors of competing products whose attributes so resemble those of the protected mark that they create the likelihood of confusion in the marketplace.

The Apple strategy is particularly important because companies typically don’t give enough attention to the management and potential value of trademarks—especially when it comes to the nontraditional variety. This is partly because trademarks, like other intellectual properties, are complex assets. But they can make a significant difference. Yamaha Motor Corp.,

To reproduce or transmit one or more MIT Sloan Management Review articles by electronic or mechanical means (including photocopying or archiving in any information storage or retrieval system) requires written permission. To request permission, visit our online store (www.pubservice.com/msstore), call or e-mail:
Toll-free: 800-876-5764 (US and Canada)
International: 818-487-2064
E-mail: MITSMR@pubservice.com

This article was printed from MIT Sloan Management Review online: http://sloanreview.mit.edu/executive-adviser/2008-2/5026/shape-of-things-to-come/

Add a comment

 

FROM THE MAGAZINE

Winter 2012: Cover Story

Winning the Race with Ever-Smarter Machines

 

Recent progress in information technology has been both rapid and dramatic. Is your company ready?