MIT Sloan Management Review

Financial Management, Marketing

 

Financial Analysis for Profit-Driven Pricing

By Gerald E. Smith and Thomas T. Nagle

April 15, 1994

PRICING DECISIONS REQUIRE A BALANCE BETWEEN COMPETING FORCES. PRICES MUST BE HIGH ENOUGH TO YIELD A PROFIT YET LOW ENOUGH TO GIVE BUYERS sufficient incentive to buy. According to the authors, many companies let one or the other of these concerns dominate pricing decisions, resulting in tactical, short-term decisions that are not connected to marketing strategy. Here they suggest a profit-driven approach to pricing that focuses on profit contribution and defines the market response necessary to achieve incremental profitability.

Internal financial considerations and external market considerations are, at most companies, antagonistic forces in pricing decisions. Financial people allocate costs to determine how high prices must be to cover costs and achieve their profit objectives. Marketing and salespeople analyze buyers to determine how low prices must be to achieve their sales objectives. The pricing decisions that result are politically charged compromises, not thoughtful implementations of a coherent strategy. Although common, this situation is neither necessary nor desirable. An effective pricing decision should involve an optimal blending of, not a compromise between, internal financial constraints and external market conditions.

Unfortunately, few managers have any idea how to facilitate such a cross-functional blending of these legitimate concerns. From traditional cost accounting, they learn to take sales objectives as “given” before allocating costs, thus precluding the ability to incorporate market forces into pricing decisions. From marketing, they are told that effective pricing should be entirely “customer driven,” ignoring costs except as a minimum constraint below which the sale would become unprofitable. Perhaps, along the way, these managers study economics and learn that, in theory, optimal pricing is a blending of cost and demand considerations. In practice, however, they find the economists’ assumption of a known demand curve hopelessly unrealistic.

Consequently, pricing at most companies remains stuck between cost-driven and customer-driven procedures that are inherently incompatible. The result is tactical... To read the complete article, login or sign-up using the form below.

 
 

In This Issue

 

Best Sellers