MIT Sloan Management Review

Leadership and Organizational Studies, Marketing

Achieving Deep Customer Focus

By Sandra Vandermerwe

April 15, 2004

The full text of this article is available free to all site visitors as part of our ongoing Business Insight series compliments of MIT Sloan Executive Education. Jointly produced by MIT Sloan Management Review and The Wall Street Journal, Business Insight offers fresh thinking on crucial management issues supplemented by the deep knowledge of related MIT SMR articles. Download article PDF

Customer-focused transformation is producing long-term, sustainable growth through a systemic, tested process. The approach gets all employees collaborating to identify the outcomes that customers need — and to help them get there.

Thanks to that tool, IHI knew exactly where customers had value gaps that the company could fill with offerings: health assessments and policy recommendations; voluntary wellness action plans for employees; monitoring of employee health; suggestions for interventions; and recommendations on the appropriate doctor or hospital wherever in the world employees happened to be. Then, to reduce the expensive failure rates of overseas job assignments, IHI incorporated advice on matching people to countries, and education and support for individuals (on issues such as jet lag, allergies, floods and terrorism). IHI also could help a company measure the wellness approach’s returns to the bottom line. And when a healthier employee reduced his or her company’s insurance claims, IHI rewarded the company with bonus points that could be traded for rebates.

Breakthrough 6: Size the Prize

The next breakthrough occurs when deep-customer-focus companies like LexisNexis see how much they can improve their numbers. The customer-activity cycle helped LexisNexis gauge the size of the gaps it could fill if customers could have up-to-the-minute databases that LexisNexis built, fed into customer routines, updated and maintained to allow users to ask better questions and get better answers instead of using slow manual or electronic-imaging sources. Customers could, for example, look at patent applications, not just patent acceptances, and be better equipped to decide if their own innovations justified applying for a patent. The opportunity amounted to 88% more than what LexisNexis had made from its core patent publications.

Sizing the prize also involves understanding that customers who buy new offerings build stronger working relationships with a company and often increase their purchases of existing offerings. Longer, wider, more diverse and deeper revenue streams translate into more wealth.

However, managers must be on guard against an ingrained corporate tendency to demand proof upfront. The only realistic way to evaluate deep-customer-focus benefits is over time, the way other corporate assets are evaluated. Companies that prefer intricate detail can use sophisticated net-present cash-flow calculations.7 But enterprises that see an opportunity big enough to justify moving forward will be content with looser calculations.

Breakthrough 7: Model the Concept

In the next stage, companies must give customers and employees proof that the concept works. And what better way to do that than to have customers become part of the action and participate in early wins. Modeling is different from testing in the level of resources used. With sufficient resources, the company can get the concept right. Then confidence surges internally and externally, and positive energy accelerates adoption of the concept —in the enterprise, out in the market and back into the enterprise — in a push-pull, buy-in loop.

Note that this is not a timid toe in the water. Too often, companies do a pilot test with a representative population and deliberately give it a low profile so that if it fails, the concept can be quickly abandoned. Modeling means taking a concept or new way of doing things (rather than a single product or service) and making it work. It thus involves the best in-house resources and a small but select group of customers — the customer points of light who “get it.”

Modeling begins with a workshop done with customers in the spirit of research — not promotion. A full-blown demonstration of the customer-activity cycle gives customers a chance to validate the value propositions and indicate what they see as “hot spots,” or critical areas. Experience shows that having the presenting company’s sponsoring senior executive at these workshops helps customers engage with the concept enough to proceed.

Demonstrating proof of concept with customers takes from three to eight months, sometimes longer. Some companies — for example, BP — have felt sufficiently confident about being able to start delivering value immediately during modeling that they charge customers or reach an agreement to share any gains. In modeling its fuel-savings concept, BP worked with key manufacturing customers to help them use, convert and reuse their energy in ways that reduced their overall energy bills and emission problems. The customers shared their savings with BP.

Some companies, however, regard modeling as an investment. Because spawning knowledge and expertise for eventual scaling up is also important, they use it as a laboratory for learning. IHI, for example, modeled its health-assessment and consulting component by taking it to an international airline and collaborating to develop ways to measure the impact of a well-being program on the bottom line. The learning investment paid off. The collaboration not only benefited the airline, it gave IHI a technique it could adapt and roll out to clients in other markets. Similarly, IHI collaborated with a group of expatriate couples to perfect its online health tool.

Breakthrough 8: Get People Working Together

Executives always say that the most challenging and perplexing part of the process is getting colleagues inside the organization, preoccupied with business as usual, to engage in a new concept seriously — infinitely more difficult, they insist, than finding outside partners. Yet colleagues must ultimately coexist, cooperate and coproduce. Closed, silolike structures, mentalities and behaviors cannot produce the desired customer outcomes.

Enlisting colleagues entails appealing to both their reason and their emotions. BP had always been renowned for its silo-based working mode. Once the enterprise decided to attempt deep customer focus, the sponsoring business units invited “points of light” from other units to collaborate early on. The invitees felt more involved and less threatened than would otherwise have been the case, and the sponsors discovered that outreach accelerates engagement.

The sponsors were able to demonstrate that no unit would lose. Even if a deeply customer-focused BP gave a customer advice on how to shrink its total energy bill, the customer would end up giving BP a bigger share of its energy spending.

Note that customer-focused internal cooperation is not the same as cross-selling. The silos must be mixed and merged to produce a genuinely unified customer experience. Consider U.K.-based Marks & Spencer. This famous, centenarian retailer rebuilt itself by providing a lifestyle experience for customers and saved itself from the brink of disaster. In the past, silos had been built around the merchandise — say, clothing, books, furnishings or financial services. Then teams began to consider themselves responsible for a “customer-lifestyle outcome.” The difference, as one executive says, is “between delivering the perfect Christmas for a family, and putting perfect Christmas turkeys on the shelves.”

Also helpful in getting people working together is to celebrate success. When a group at LexisNexis successfully modeled a concept designed to help e-business customers make instant decisions on whether to transact with someone visiting their Web sites, all of LexisNexis celebrated the group’s accomplishment. That recognition accelerated companywide customer focus and unleashed a myriad of initiatives.

Breakthrough 9: Get Critical Mass

When enough customers respond to a company’s deep customer focus (“enough” might be 10 customers or 50 million, depending on the circumstances), the company begins to enjoy the hoped-for sustainable benefits.

How do companies accelerate the transition from modeling the concept to acquiring enough customers to reach a critical mass? One way is to make it easy for customers to say yes. Consider a public-sector example. The U.K. government’s pharmacy-reform initiative makes pharmacists more responsible for managing patients’ medicine (thereby easing waiting and waste in the National Health Service). The initiative has taken off in part because neither patients nor pharmacists risk being penalized by saying yes. Patients who still need to go to their physicians get rapid access. Pharmacists, more involved in their communities and good at identifying symptoms among certain groups — predispositions, say, to asthma or diabetes — benefit, too. As pharmacists work to prevent disease and help people use medications properly or pursue a healthful lifestyle, they may earn less from filling prescriptions. However, they gain consulting fees from the government and are supported with training and contract agreements to eliminate the administrative hassles of getting paid.

Another way to speed up customer acceptance and the rewards to the company is to make the initiative easy on customers’ finances. HSC, for example, doesn’t charge when checking to see whether patients have the necessary facilities and emotional support for postoperative home care. If a patient’s home setup is lacking, HSC advises on what is needed. Similarly, IBM ensures that on-demand computing is affordable enough for customers to take it up — they pay only when they actually use the service, just as they do for utilities such as electricity or water.

A third way is to quantify both the financial and nonfinancial benefits to customers. That requires collecting “before” and “after” baseline statistics, as well as gathering statements from customers verbalizing the intangible benefits they seek. Lexis-Nexis asked one customer group, insurance-claims assessors, “What do you consider success?” and found out that success meant increasing the number of frauds detected and the amount of money recovered. LexisNexis used those performance criteria to measure and communicate its worth to customers.

The market needs to be created and educated all at once. If the company fails to make the new approach indispensable to key customers, it will struggle to attain “enough” and reach the critical mass. Witness Monsanto Co.’s continuing uphill battle to get bioengineered crops understood and accepted in Europe.

Old-fashioned marketing techniques with their short-term focus cannot help a concept gain critical mass. The company must make a genuine investment. IHI invested in creating a well-being university to educate both individuals and corporations on the tangible benefits of wellness. And to broaden understanding and acceptance of the concept, IHI invests in collaboration with leading global corporations and health experts on research, forums and publications, benefiting customers and company alike.

Such investments fill gaps in the customer-activity cycle, enabling quicker, better results. Says an executive from IBM, “We can see a clear correlation between investments that are lined up behind specific business values for a customer rather than those that we make across the board. The returns are not only larger, but also more predictable.”

Investments should be made as early as possible, to prevent competitors from getting a foothold. HSC invests in assessments at a patient’s home, LexisNexis in its initial consulting. IBM made a considerable investment by acquiring the consulting arm of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC). With the insights of 3,000 PwC researchers, IBM is better able to predict future developments in technology and how they will affect client organizations.

Breakthrough 10: Gather Momentum

As customers seeking a certain outcome begin to find the company indispensable to that end, they influence other potential customers. That’s when the anticipated financial rewards begin to flow, and an enterprise realizes the payback from deep customer focus. (See “Ten Breakthroughs Lead to Exponential Growth,” p. 31.)

Significantly, because most investments that create customer value are intangible (skills, information, knowledge, expertise, partnering), they can be used over and over without any depreciation. In fact, the cost of use decreases. Knowledge, once accumulated, can be adapted quickly and scaled up to allow an enterprise to expand into new markets and geographic areas at low cost. That differs from traditional assets.

The investments that foster customer focus also differ in being expandable. The initial outlay for, say, technological infrastructure is only a baseline cost requiring occasional refreshment. Deep-customer-focus investments do not require the expense companies pour into upgrading or replacing capital assets such as buildings, stores, factories or oil rigs.

The result? Real potential for an exponential reward. With knowledge as the main ingredient in customer value, the enterprise can keep ahead of competitors. Thus, in the gather-momentum stage of the process, the key concern of executives should not be, “Do we own ‘it’?” but rather, “Do we understand how to do ‘it’?” and, “Are we using, reusing and updating our knowledge?”

The trick is to capture knowledge gleaned from behavior or encounters unique to an individual customer and then reuse it by consolidating the findings and transferring the relevant pieces to other customers. LexisNexis, for one, continuously observes customer behavior to track how users link information in their decision-making processes. The company then aggregates what it learns into new value for other customers.

Equally important is collecting knowledge gained in the field from internal colleagues to create best and future practices. Thus HSC seeks to understand in minute detail which region is getting the best results — which nurse is getting the best results with which patient, why and how? The best practices are then disseminated across the enterprise and constantly updated, allowing HSC to maintain its lead as the standard in the market.

Making Customer Focus Stick

No one would call becoming truly customer focused easy. But it is the only way to outpace others, both newcomers who appear out of nowhere to seize the limelight and new wealth and those incumbents who persist in using short-term tactics and strategies to compete. When an enterprise has made the breakthroughs and customer focus gets deep into its essence, the concept will take root in behavior and shape all subsequent innovative actions. (See “Deep Customer Focus Success Factors,” p. 33.)

At that point, customer focus sticks and becomes a permanent imprint in the culture. Employees become programmed to creatively and constantly innovate to keep the enterprise indispensable to customers. Successes can be repeated, and enterprises can continue renewing themselves in their quest for profitable growth in futures they themselves may have to invent.

(Reprint #:45307)

Pages: 1 2

Sandra Vandermerwe, a professor of international marketing and services at Tanaka Business School, Imperial College, University of London, specializes in customer focus transformation strategies. Contact her at s.vandermerwe@imperial.ac.uk.

REFERENCES

1. A strong body of research has evolved around the importance of customer focus in innovation and strategic growth, and the importance of interacting with customers and delivering a unique experience to them. For recent relevant works, see R.C. Blattberg, G. Getz and J.S. Thomas, “Customer Equity: Building and Managing Relationships as Valuable Assets” (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 2001); C.M. Christensen and M.E. Raynor, “The Innovator’s Solution: Creating and Sustaining Successful Growth” (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 2003); F.R. Reichheld, “The Loyalty Effect: The Hidden Force Behind Growth, Profits and Lasting Value” (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 2001); and A.J. Slywotzky and R. Wise, “The Growth Crisis — And How To Escape It,” Harvard Business Review 80 (July 2002): 72–84. Discussions of customer interactions include G.S. Day, “Creating a Superior Customer-Relating Capability,” MIT Sloan Management Review 44 (spring 2003): 77–82; and M. Vandenbosch and N. Dawar, “Beyond Better Products: Capturing Value in Customer Interactions,” MIT Sloan Management Review 43 (summer 2002): 35–42. Major works on customer experience include B.J. Pine II and J. Gilmore, “The Experience Economy: Work Is Theatre and Every Business a Stage” (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1999); C.K. Prahalad and V. Ramaswamy, “The Future of Competition: Co-Creating Unique Value With Customers” (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 2003).

2. Organizational transformation continues as a critical area of study, but to date, the literature in change management has not explicitly dealt with how to use the principles and practice to achieve a customer focus successfully. A notable work on change management is J.P. Kotter and D.S. Cohen, “The Heart of Change: Real-Life Stories of How People Change Their Organizations” (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 2002). For related work on the public sector, see W. Chan Kim and R.A. Mauborgne, “Tipping Point Leadership,” Harvard Business Review 81 (April 2003): 66–75.

3. S. Vandermerwe, “How Increasing Value to Customers Improves Business Results,” Sloan Management Review 42 (fall 2000): 27–37.

4. For an example of recent research on the importance of energizers in evoking emotional reactions that lead to improved organizational performance, see R. Cross, W. Baker and A. Parker, “What Creates Energy in Organizations?” MIT Sloan Management Review 44 (summer 2003): 51–56.

5. A market space is defined as a desired customer outcome. It extends boundaries beyond core products and services but also frames the new competitive arena for the enterprise. See S. Vandermerwe, “New Competitive Spaces: Jointly Investing in New Customer Logic,” Columbia Journal of World Business 31 (winter 1996): 80–102; and S. Vandermerwe, “Customer Capitalism: Getting Increasing Returns in New ‘Market Spaces’” (London: Nicholas Brealey, 1999).

6. The customer-activity cycle has three phases: pre, during and post, and maps the entire experience needed to get a customer outcome. Each phase has subcycles, sub-subcycles, sub-sub-subcycles and so forth to get to the level of detail that uncovers the opportunities. See S. Vandermerwe, “Jumping Into the Customer’s Activity Cycle: A New Role for Customer Services in the 1990s,” Columbia Journal of World Business 28 (summer 1993): 46–66. For the experiences of corporations using the tool as they make the transformation from products to customers, see S. Vandermerwe, “The Eleventh Commandment: Transforming To ‘Own’ Customers” (London: John Wiley & Sons, 1996).

7. For an example of how scholars calculate the lifetime value of customers, see E. Ofek, “Customer Profitability and Lifetime Value,” Harvard Business School case no. 9-503-019 (Boston: Harvard Business School Publishing, 2002); R. Rust, V. Zeithaml and K. Lemon, “Driving Customer Equity: How Customer Lifetime Value Is Reshaping Corporate Strategy” (New York: Free Press, 2000); and R.K. Srivastava, T.A. Shervani and L. Fahey, “Market-Based Assets and Shareholder Value: A Framework for Analysis,” Journal of Marketing 62, no. 1 (1998): 2–18.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Comments posted on this site must be signed with your full, real name. Please see our Comments policy for details.

From The Magazine

Fall 2009

Special Report: Sustainability

8 Reasons That Sustainability Will Change Management

Michael S. Hopkins

Transparency, accidental innovation, trust, collaboration — as sustainability affects how the world works, so will it affect how business works in the world.

Intelligence: Management

Debunking Management Myths

Martha E. Mangelsdorf

In this interview, Henry Mintzberg questions some of the conventional wisdom about managerial work.