Return-to-Office Mandates: How to Lose Your Best Performers

Your organization’s highest-performing employees want executives to focus on outcomes and accountability, not office badge swipes.

Reading Time: 11 min 

Topics

Column

Our expert columnists offer opinion and analysis on important issues facing modern businesses and managers.
More in this series
Permissions and PDF

Carolyn Geason-Beissel/MIT SMR | Getty Images

Editor’s note: Since we originally published this story, even more data has come to light on the effects of RTO mandates. We have updated this story with a video in which Brian Elliott explores the newest RTO mandate research and lessons learned from company examples. He also shares predictions for what’s coming next for companies like Amazon that have imposed RTO mandates. Watch the embedded video at the bottom of this story.

Recent return-to-office (RTO) mandates like those at UPS and Boeing have a simple message: Come back to the office five days a week. CEOs cite productivity as a core reason for these proclamations, even in the face of employee resistance. Many executives simply don’t trust that employees are as effective as possible when managers can’t see them at their desks.

But in a world of globally distributed teams, falling back on management-through-monitoring is falling back on the weakest form of management — and one that drives down employee engagement. There is mounting evidence that mandates don’t improve financial performance. Instead, they damage employee engagement and increase attrition, especially among high-performing employees and particularly those with caregiving responsibilities.

There is a better way forward, but it requires culture work at the top as well as deep within organizations, along with a significant upgrade in management philosophy. Too many organizational cultures use face time at the office as their metric for productivity. That’s not the best benchmark. Instead, focusing on outcomes while providing trust and flexibility about where and when to get work done allows individuals and organizations to thrive.

What’s Behind the RTO Drive

We’re four years past the start of the pandemic-driven shift toward flexible work. While the peak of remote work has passed for now, office utilization in the U.S. has been effectively flat. For the past year, it’s been hovering at 50% of pre-pandemic norms.

RTO pronouncements have come loud and clear from Amazon, Google, IBM, JPMorgan Chase, and more. Some CEOs talk about the solidarity that office workers need to have with front-line workers, although Gallup research shows that a strong majority of front-line workers aren’t bothered by office worker flexibility. In fact, they want flexibility themselves, including a choice of which days to work, the option for four 10-hour days, and some flextime — in other words, equity, not equality.

Topics

Column

Our expert columnists offer opinion and analysis on important issues facing modern businesses and managers.
More in this series

Reprint #:

65437

More Like This

Add a comment

You must to post a comment.

First time here? Sign up for a free account: Comment on articles and get access to many more articles.

Comment (1)
Shawna Unger
Well written, detailed and accurate.  We are seeing in our work that the echo chamber of CEOs making an all or nothing decision in this space to RTO 5 days a week are paying a price.
undefined