We asked our panel of strategy experts to tell us how strongly they agree with this statement:

Introducing 5G networks 3-5 years ahead of other countries will give Chinese firms an advantage.

RAW RESPONSES
WEIGHTED BY CONFIDENCE

Raw Responses

Responses weighted by panelists’ level of confidence

Across the world, the race to deploy 5G — next-generation internet connectivity — is heating up, with several countries in contention for offering this powerful network technology first. 5G will offer much faster networks for businesses and consumers and enable new advances in internet of things technology. China, South Korea, the U.S., and Japan are among the countries most likely to make the first commercial 5G network debut, and for the U.S. and China in particular, the technology has become a focal point in an escalating trade war. This month, we asked our panel of strategy experts to examine the competitive scenario if China were to achieve a 5G rollout first.

Panelist Vote Confidence Comments Profile & Vote History
Holden, Richard

Richard Holden

University of New South Wales
Agree 6 “I think it depends on how strong the network externalities are and the degree to which 5G technology once installed can be replaced with superior technology.” Profile / Vote History
Van Reenen, John

John Van Reenen

MIT
Agree 5 “First-mover advantages are often exaggerated.” Profile / Vote History
Arora, Ashish

Ashish Arora

Duke University
Strongly Agree 5 “Pioneers do not always benefit. But in this case, it seems likely that they will.” Profile / Vote History
Gans, Joshua

Joshua Gans

University of Toronto
Agree 8 “A 5G network that is built earlier in a region moves businesses in that region into the future sooner. They can experiment with new products and services and be further up the learning curve. The cost is that global demand for those services is still far off, which diminishes their relative advantage.” Profile / Vote History
McAfee, R. Preston

R. Preston McAfee

Economist
Agree 8 “Early experience, learning by doing, control of standards, and large scale will provide an advantage to equipment manufacturers like Huawei and ZTE, and to handset suppliers, especially with barriers to foreign firms in the Chinese telephony market.” Profile / Vote History
Greenstein, Shane

Shane Greenstein

Harvard University
Strongly Agree 9 “There are no compelling applications for 5G yet, but there are many promising prototypes in security, entertainment, and logistics. Give inventive and competent firms time to explore, and they will invent something and figure out how to get revenue from it. More time is a big advantage.” Profile / Vote History
McGahan, Anita

Anita McGahan

University of Toronto
Agree 7 “Faster internet connectivity gives firms an edge in market analysis of all types, including financial. It gives firms an edge in responding to opportunities. The question here is whether access to 5G networks in China will be restricted to Chinese firms. If so, and if Chinese companies are not restricted internationally from access to data, then 5G will confer an advantage on them.” Profile / Vote History
Florida, Richard

Richard Florida

University of Toronto
Neither Agree nor Disagree 7 “Yes and no. “Yes” because it will create significant first-mover advantage in a huge market. “No” because it ultimately depends on whether the U.S. can freeze Chinese companies out of Western markets. This will be interesting to watch.” Profile / Vote History
Lyon, Tom

Tom Lyon

University of Michigan
Strongly Agree 8 “A technological lead is usually valuable. This may be especially important in autonomous vehicle technology, which will rely on 5G networks.” Profile / Vote History
Roberts, John

John Roberts

Stanford University
Agree 5 Profile / Vote History
Nalebuff, Barry

Barry Nalebuff

Yale University
Agree 6 “But how much of an advantage? How much did Minitel help the French in the long run? And given potential for spyware via Chinese hardware, being a second-mover might be a better position in the long run. One big gain to 5G seems to be competition to cable providers. Not sure how much that makes a difference to overall economy.” Profile / Vote History
Stern, Scott

Scott Stern

MIT
Agree 6 “There are multiple versions of 5G, and many companies and countries are trying to leapfrog in this area, but some of the key strategic adoption initiatives in China are likely to allow Chinese firms such as Huawei to have some advantages over competitors such as Ericsson and Nokia. But not sure if these advantages are decisive.” Profile / Vote History
Moser, Petra

Petra Moser

New York University
Strongly Agree 10 “Whoever gets access to 5G first will be first to develop new technologies that require superfast speed, reduced lag time, or increased network capacity. A lag of three to five years creates a head start for Chinese firms that will be difficult to close.” Profile / Vote History
Tadelis, Steve

Steve Tadelis

University of California, Berkeley
Agree 8 “It is typically the case that having access to early technology adoption leads to a leg up on introducing and benefiting from complementary technologies and innovations.” Profile / Vote History
Henderson, Rebecca

Rebecca Henderson

Harvard University
Strongly Agree 8 “The degree of advantage is heavily dependent, of course, on how good the Chinese technology proves to be.” Profile / Vote History
Sorenson, Olav

Olav Sorenson

Yale University
Disagree 8 “If China actually beats other countries by three-plus years, it probably would give Chinese firms an advantage. But it’s unclear that they will. 5G has already begun being deployed in Korea and the U.S. It’s also not clear whether the version that China adopts will become the standard. If it does not, early deployment might even become a disadvantage.” Profile / Vote History
Simcoe, Timothy

Timothy Simcoe

Boston University
Strongly Disagree 8 “Which Chinese firms? Not the carriers, for whom competition is local. Not device makers, for whom 5G (because it’s a standard) will not be a differentiating feature. Maybe infrastructure producers, like Huawei or ZTE, but it looks like security concerns will harm them in the U.S., and their real advantage in addressable markets is cost-based.” Profile / Vote History
Brynjolfsson, Erik

Erik Brynjolfsson

MIT
Strongly Agree 7 “5G is a big deal, and the U.S. is fumbling its rollout.” Profile / Vote History
Schilling, Melissa

Melissa Schilling

New York University
Agree 10 “Access to 5G infrastructure and customers on 5G connections will enable Chinese firms to develop a wide range of products and services that will be more advanced than those in countries without 5G. There will be second-mover advantages for the other countries, but it could still take a while to catch up.” Profile / Vote History
Brown, Jennifer

Jennifer Brown

University of Utah
Neither Agree nor Disagree 6 “The advantage here isn’t obvious. Local demand may spur local innovation (and a head start on 5G tech development), but not necessarily in a way that precludes non-Chinese firms from jumping in now or later. Moreover, the international success or failure of Chinese firms may be sensitive to other countries’ tech and security policy three to five years from now.” Profile / Vote History
Rosenkopf, Lori

Lori Rosenkopf

University of Pennsylvania
Agree 8 “Working infrastructure, coupled with the large protected domestic market, will stimulate massive commercialization of related and complementary products and services by Chinese firms, which in turn will accelerate technological development.” Profile / Vote History
Levinthal, Daniel

Daniel Levinthal

University of Pennsylvania
Agree 8 “The Chinese government can be expected to privilege national firms in building out this network and technology providers whose systems will interface with this platform.” Profile / Vote History